5.Conclusion
Diciembre 1, 2011
Talking about disguise, it is remarkable that in all the plays that we have seen during the first and the second paper, the main disguise is a female changing into another female or a male. As we have seen based on the book of Victor Oscar Freeburg, this is a thing originated because of the social characteristics of the time, this is because the fact that all the actors were men at that time. This feature influenced the plays and the plots, because a girl disguised as a man would not be recognizable, mainly, because all the actors were men.
We have to take all those changes into account to fully understand every Shakespearean comedy, This is, is important to know, as we have mentioned before, that all the actors were male, and this was a fact that from my point of view limited the performance of the play in a way. This also happened with the social relations that we can find in those plays, for instance, in the play mentioned in this second paper, ‘The Merchant of Venice’, we see the figure of Shylock, and we have to take into consideration, as Lee Lady says in some articles about Shakespeare, that we have to take into consideration that the audience of Shakespeare consist mainly in merchants, craftsmen and businessmen and for them usury was an evil. Not just because it was condemned in the Bible, but because usurers lent money at high interested rates to desperate businessmen and then ruined them by foreclosing on their assets when they were unable to pay. Today this usury has become very common in our lives as we have the banks offering us lots of credit cards, so it is difficult to look at the play through Elizabethan eyes. ‘One would have to rewrite it and make Shylock into a villain who it’s socially acceptable to condemn, such as drug dealer to see that Shakespeare’s audience saw Portia’s swindling of Shylock (and certainly she did swindle him, coming into court disguised as an impartial expert witness) as nothing less than simple justice. And certainly they saw Portia as a heroine, not a persecutor of an innocent victim.’
As the third point in my conclusion I want to remark the way that disguise gives a mistaken identity (identity is in part constructed by clothes, meaning that it is surface rather than real identity of a person) and the way in which you can play with it. For instance, there are disguises that change the genre as Viola-Cesario and others that maintains the same genre as Feste when disguises himself as a priest. This sentence leads us to the point, that this mistaken identity can be also a kind of a critique to the gender and the love between people from the same sex. As we have seen for instance in ‘Twelfth Night’, where we can see a female (Olivia), in love with Viola (which in that moment is Cesario). For me, is like a way in which Shakespeare makes a critique saying that what is most important in the inside of a person, the personality, not just the way they appear.
And finally, in this paper we have seen, how disguised roled in the three plays seen. So we know that all the disguises there are not the same. For instance, there are disguises that influenced directly in the plot, and change it, as Rosalin or Portia, or disguises that do not influence in the play directly as Viola. That doesn’t mean that the disguise is not importat in the play, it is simply that it is in the plot itself. It doesn’t appear in a certain moment to change the way in which events are happening
Leave a Reply